Should this be happening??? anyone can answer?

so i think that i have fallen for a couple of guys...is it normal for one person to like/be infatuated with more than one person? how do you choose which one is best for you? i am really lost and i have two guys...i am taking a break from the whole dating thing to get my head screwed on right (for those of you that read my other ?s shut up and be happy). i have one guy that is likes me for everything (but loves the physicallity) and the other guy just loves ME not just one thing or not two things but ME as a whole. Should i be in love with both of them? how can i stop being in love with one of them? which one should i be in love with?